Hello dear
"Papa Tinos Pizzeria" in Watertown, NY, is a haven for pizza and wings enthusiasts. With a diverse range of toppings and specialty pizzas like the Italian Deluxe and Buffalo Chicken, their menu offers something for everyone. Customers rave about their perfectly crispy wings, especially the unique Suicide flavor. The standout dish is the Chicken Cordon Bleu pizza, known for its dense and flavorful combination of alfredo sauce, chicken, and garlic option. With friendly service and ample portion sizes, Papa Tinos Pizzeria is a must-visit for a satisfying Italian dining experience.
About
Welcome to Papa Tinos Pizzeria, a hidden gem located at 716 Mill St in Watertown, NY. This Italian restaurant offers a variety of delicious pizzas, chicken wings, and more. With options for delivery, takeout, and even reservations, Papa Tinos Pizzeria caters to all your dining needs.
One of the highlights of this place is their extensive pizza menu, featuring classics like Cheese Pizza and specialty options like Italian Deluxe and Mediterranean Fresh. The Calzones are also a must-try, stuffed with your favorite fillings.
Customers rave about the wings at Papa Tinos Pizzeria, with flavors like Suicide, Taco, and Thai Chili impressing even the most discerning wing enthusiasts. And don't miss out on their signature dish - the Chicken Cordon Bleu pizza, a dense and flavorful masterpiece that will keep you coming back for more.
While some dishes may be standard fare, like the breadsticks and fried appetizers, the real standout at Papa Tinos Pizzeria is their pizza and wings. With crispy crusts, generous toppings, and unique flavor combinations, this place is a go-to spot for a satisfying meal.
Whether you're a local looking for a new favorite spot or just passing through the area, Papa Tinos Pizzeria is worth a visit. With a casual atmosphere, good for kids and groups, this restaurant has something for everyone. So, don't miss out on the culinary delights that await you at Papa Tinos Pizzeria.
“ Great service! Great food. Tricky with fried food. Sometimes isn't cooked all the way. Other than that, their dessert and other food is AMAZING! ”
“ They definitely have amazing food I order up the good work guys. I especially love their pizza and wings. 1through 10. In my opinion, they are a 10. ”
“ It seems like random chance we even came across this place. The physical location is super easy to miss, and nobody's really screaming the name from the rooftops like it seems like they should be. We're newish to the area, and so far these are the best wings we've had here, and in a long time. Whenever we order wings, we request extra sauce, and extra crispy. So few places go the distance with that, it's a disappointment we've come to expect. So this was extra nerve racking ordering on their website, where the wings don't even have input for special instructions. We rolled the dice on default wings with no instruction, and somehow they came through like few other places do. We've ordered wings here three times, and they've been perfect every time. Some of our favorite wings anywhere. First wings we ordered were Suicide. Whenever a place has some kind of extreme hot sauce, we always have to try it. This was pretty exciting, because they already even had an Xtra Hot version. I haven't confirmed it, but it seems like Suicide isn't just another step up from Hot - it seems to be its own thing entirely. I spent a lot of time trying to figure out exactly what, and then some additional time on exactly why. It's not crazy spicy, but it's got a unique taste that includes cinnamon. If we're being honest, it tastes like the first Indian curry you tried to make before you got the spices down. I happened to love my Frankenstein curries, and when we stopped overthinking these wings, they grew on us pretty hard. We'll absolutely get these again. Did anyone else ever mix all the fountain drinks together in one cup and call it a "suicide drink"? Because that might actually be what they're going for here. Second one we ordered was Taco. We were super curious and just wanted to know. Rather than ask, we just went for it on our 2nd trip there. They come in an oily sauce, then have a side of sour cream and a side of salsa. The oily sauce tastes exactly like the oil from your taco meat... it was actually wild how well this whole get up emulated the taco experience. It was a lot of work and now that the novelty is through, I'd rather just have other wings. Third order we did Thai Chili. That one was super sweet and definitely had soy sauce, which made it resemble teriyaki. The taste was pretty mild, and while we liked it a lot, there are at least a dozen other sauces I'd be dying to try before going back to this one. All the wings are so perfectly crispy, every time. They're exactly how wings oughta be and it blows our minds. Until further notice, this will be our spot when our wings have to be perfect. The pizza is good, but the one worth raving about is the chicken cordon bleu. First of all, this thing was so dense we ate it leftover for three more meals before it was gone. On the site, we checked "garlic option", and I'm not sure what that added to the pizza, but it was intense. The alfredo sauce was thick and surprisingly rich. The crust was thick and so good we'd order a plain pie with nothing on it and it would still make top 10. I don't know if it was the breading from the chicken or the contents of the sauce, but the whole thing came together to form its own soft, bready layer between the dough and the cheese. We had just made some Italian dressing at home, and we used the whole jar on this single pizza. If you have access to a good Italian dressing, try it with this pizza. The other two pizzas we got were meat lovers and pepperoni. The first one we got we asked for double cut, and I think they might have at least triple cut it. It almost felt like they were mocking us for having made the request. The pepperoni is good, nothing special. The meat lovers was thick, and reminded us of the old Nice N Easy pizzas we used to get. Basically a vehicle for as much bleu cheese as you can fit onto it. The rest of the food was barely anything to write about. Just standard issue Sysco stock, cooked per the instructions on the box. The fried cauliflower and fried cheese curd were good, but surely the same product you'd find in the frozen section at a grocery store. Even the cheesesteak was pretty standard. The breadsticks were very similar to what you'd get from Pizza Hut. So, good, but throw out whatever you don't eat - especially if you're afraid to chip a tooth or lose a crown. We ordered them because we had made marinara sauce at home and needed a vehicle for it. We tried the sauce they provided and it would have made the entire order a waste. A lot of words being said here in the name of a pizzeria, so let's try to make it simple. Try the Chicken Cordon Bleu pizza, and try it with good Italian Dressing. Be prepared to have leftovers. Try whatever wings you can get your hands on. They will be crispy and the sauce will be good and plentiful. Tons of stuff we haven't tried yet so take it from here. ”
“ It was our first time here and everyone in the kitchen was so friendly and welcoming. There were several takeouts while we were there. Our large pizza was enough for us to have plenty for the next day. My spouse thought it was the best pizza he had eaten this summer. I got 2 cookies to take home for dessert and they were delicious. ”
“ I truly do not understand all the bad prior reviews. I've been ordering pizza here for years and have never had a bad meal! Pizza is always hot and freshly made, and super tasty. Prices are fair. Order is always ready on time. There's seating if you want to eat there, but I always just pick up and take it home. The giant party pizzas are a great option if you need to feed a crowd. I recommend this place all the time when someone is wondering where they should order pizza in the area. ”
“ Pizza is excellent! Ready in a timely fashion. Recommend. We always do takeout but there are tables for eating in. ”
“ The service is always top notch. The employees are always friendly and the food is fantastic! They recently had an issue with their online ordering and they went out of their way to contact customers to let them know what was going on and to make sure their orders still got submitted. By far the best pizza, wings and salads in town. Thanks for all you guys do! ”
“ Great pizza place ! The tomato sauce is superb !!! The giant pizza is our go to for get togethers ! highly recommend ! ”
“ Great food great prices and superb Service A Must Try and They make Great Hand held Deserts also ”